Scientists list 50 terms you may be confusing

Science-education-communication-confused-terms

“Prejudice” is often used interchangeably with “discrimination” though the terms have different meanings. Image from Shutterstock.

Psychopath vs sociopath, antisocial vs asocial, serial killer vs mass murderer and 47 other terms that seem to be the same but aren’t

— By Emma Duncan

Should you punish a disobedient child, or try negative reinforcement? Is your shy new colleague antisocial or asocial? And which is worse: a prejudiced boss or a discriminatory one?

Most comprehensive list of confused terms

These are just three examples of psychological terms that are commonly assumed to be similar, if not identical, but which in fact refer to very different concepts. The confusion extends from television shows and science writing to textbooks and even scholarly articles.

A new paper published in Frontiers in Education defines 50 such “term pairs” related to psychology. As the most comprehensive list of its kind, the paper aims to improve the psychological literacy of psychology students as well as the broader public.

Other examples of frequently confused terms include race/ethnicity, envy/jealousy, and disease/illness.

“Words matter, and science is no exception,” says Scott O. Lilienfeld, professor of psychology at Emory University, USA, and one of the paper’s authors. “All sciences rely on specialized terminology which must be correctly understood to master the field’s core concepts.”

“In psychology, many terms are confused not only by new students but also by advanced students, psychology instructors, and science journalists. These misunderstandings can impede the learning of other psychological ideas.”

The paper, “50 Differences That Make a Difference: A Compendium of Frequently Confused Term Pairs in Psychology”, follows an earlier list of 50 widely used psychological terms that should generally be avoided.

Here’s a short definition of the term pairs above:

1. Negative reinforcement involves the withdrawal of a stimulus and increases the likelihood of a previous behavior, while punishment involves the presentation of a stimulus and decreases the likelihood of a previous behavior. So if you want to lower the likelihood of further disobedience, punishment is the way to go (although most psychological research suggests that punishment works well in the short-term, but not in the long-term).

2. Your new colleague is most likely asocial. Antisocial people perform actions against others, frequently engaging in reckless, irresponsible, and at times illegal behaviors. In contrast, asocial people chronically withdraw from others due to shyness or not being interested in interpersonal contact.

3. Prejudice refers to a belief, discrimination to a behavior. Specifically, prejudice means arriving at a premature – and usually negative – judgment of others based on their membership in one or more categories (e.g., African-American, Jew, obese, Republican), whereas discrimination refers to the act of treating others poorly as a function of this membership. While both are bad, you’d probably prefer that your boss be prejudiced.

4. Race refers to a class, such as Caucasian or African-American, that is defined by biological differences such as white versus brown or black skin. Ethnicity is a broader concept, such as German or Chinese-American, that includes race as well as cultural variables such as country of origin, customs, and preferred language.

5. Envy and jealousy are so frequently confused (e.g., “I’m jealous that you’re going to Hawaii next week!”) that few people are aware they differ. Yet the distinction is typically simple: Envy involves two people, whereas jealousy involves three or more people. So you are envious, not jealous, that your friend is headed to Hawaii — unless they are going with another friend as well.

6. A serial killer kills multiple people in a string of incidents that are separated by “cooling off” periods, whereas a mass murderer kills a large number of people in a single incident. Serial killers are also different from spree killers, whose homicidal episodes are not separated by clear-cut cooling-off periods.

7. According to most sociologists and cultural anthropologists, disease is the specific pathology or malfunctioning of a body part, and illness is the afflicted individual’s reactions to the disease.

Other widely confused terms listed in the paper include:

“Conformity” versus “obedience.” Both terms refer to forms of social influence but differ in at least two ways. In conformity, the direction of social influence is “horizontal” from one or more peers to an individual, whereas in obedience the direction is “vertical” from one or more authority figures to an individual. Moreover, in conformity, the influence is typically implicit (unspoken), whereas in obedience, it is typically explicit.

“Sex” versus “gender.” The latest edition of the American Psychological Association’s style manual reserves “sex” for biological differences and “gender” for social differences. For example, when referring to men and women in the context of socially defined groups, one should typically use gender, not sex.

“Anxiety” versus “fear.” Although many use these terms interchangeably, there is evidence that they differ both psychologically and physiologically. Anxiety is associated with negative affect in the presence of an ambiguous and potentially avoidable threat, whereas fear is associated with negative affect in the presence of an imminent and largely unavoidable threat. Even after the threat is gone, anxiety tends to persist whereas fear tends to diminish or disappear.

“Empathy” versus “sympathy.” Most authors define empathy as the capacity to appreciate or grasp the emotions of others. In sympathy, the individual typically experiences concern or compassion for the other person but does not necessarily have the same emotional experience.

“Repression” versus “suppression.” In psychoanalytic lingo, repression is a defense mechanism marked by the unconscious motivated forgetting of unpleasant material. In contrast, suppression is a defense mechanism marked by the conscious forgetting of this material.

“Shame” versus “guilt.” Most research suggests that shame reflects a global negative evaluation of oneself following a problematic or unethical behavior (“I am bad”), whereas guilt reflects a more specific negative evaluation of this behavior (“I did a bad thing”).

“Delusion” versus “hallucination.” These terms are widely confused in popular culture and occasionally in peer-reviewed literature as well. Delusions are fixed false beliefs that are not widely shared by members of the individual’s culture or subculture, whereas hallucinations are perceptual experiences that occur in the absence of any sensory stimulation.

“Obsession” versus “compulsion.” According to the latest edition of the American Psychiatric Association’s Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM), obsessions are “recurrent and persistent thoughts urges or images that are experienced as intrusive or unwanted” whereas compulsions are “repetitive behaviors or mental acts that an individual feels driven to perform in response to an obsession or according to rules that must be applied rigidly”.

“Schizophrenia” versus “multiple personality disorder.” These terms are very often misused in popular culture, following the incorrect formula of “multiple personality = split personality = schizophrenia”. Schizophrenia is characterized by a severe splitting of functions, such as cognition, emotion, and motivation, within a single person. In multiple personality disorder, now termed dissociative identity disorder, the individual’s mind ostensibly harbors two or more distinct “alters,” that is, personalities or “personality states.”

“Symptom” versus “sign.” Symptoms are subjective and must be reported by patients, whereas signs are largely objective and can be observed by clinicians and others.

“Transgender” versus “transvestite.” A transgendered person possesses a gender identity that differs from his or her biological sex, while a transvestite is someone who dresses in clothing that differs from that traditionally worn by members of his or her biological sex.

“Prevalence” versus “incidence.” Prevalence refers to the proportion of individuals in a population with a given condition. Incidence refers to the rate of emergence of new cases of individuals with a condition over a specified time interval.

“Risk factor” versus “cause.” A risk factor is a variable that (a) precedes the onset of a disorder and (b) is associated with a heightened likelihood of developing this disorder. Nevertheless, not all risk factors are causal risk factors. For example, although attentional dysfunction often precedes the onset of schizophrenia and is statistically associated with this condition, it may not itself contribute to schizophrenia. In contrast, the death of a loved one appears to both precede, and be causally related to risk for, the onset of major depression.

“Coma” versus “persistent vegetative state.” People in a coma are unable to respond to external stimulation, such as light or sound; cannot be awakened, respond to verbal commands, or initiate purposeful actions; and lack a normal sleep-wake cycle. People in a persistent vegetative state (PVS; recently renamed unresponsive wakefulness syndrome) lack normal awareness of the self and environment, but retain the sleep-wake cycle as well as certain reflexes and automatic responses such as yawning, grimacing, moaning, and opening eyes during feeding. The person’s level of consciousness may also vary in response to stimulation. A coma typically lasts less than a month, after which the person emerges with no or varying degrees of brain damage. In contrast, a PVS can last for many years and cause permanent cognitive and functional disability.

“Testing” versus “assessment.” Psychological testing refers to administration of self-report indices, interviews, intelligence tests and other measures to individuals. Psychological assessment refers to the integration and interpretation of test scores, almost always in conjunction with other information (e.g., life history data, behavioral observations during testing) to draw inferences concerning the individual’s mental status.


See the original paper for a full definition of all 50 terms: 50 Differences That Make a Difference: A Compendium of Frequently Confused Term Pairs in Psychology

Earlier list of 50 widely used psychological terms that should generally be avoided

Corresponding author: Scott O. Lilienfeld

9 Comments on Scientists list 50 terms you may be confusing

  1. Some of these ‘corrections’ aren’t correct. ‘Positive Punishment’ is the application of a stimulus to discourage a behaviour, not punishment in general. Negative punishment (removal of a stimulus to discourage a behaviour) also exists. Thus the definition given is just as inaccurate as the misconception.

    Also, Jealousy is specifically fear/concern/anxiety that something or someone you value may be taken, usually by a third party. Envy is a feeling of inadequacy and covetousness towards someone or something. The example given is incorrect: you could very well be envious of your two friends going to hawaii if you can’t afford to go, but you might be jealous if you are worried they might become best friends over there (and leave you out!). There’s more to these complex emotions than a number’s game

    Like

    • Robert Carnegie // October 12, 2017 at 2:02 am // Reply

      The words may have these particular meanings in science (I’d check carefully how “race” is used; I suppose it’s involved in questions of disease and drug efficacy where there are genetic differences, although any two people will be different except probably twins), but they were used by laymen first – or in the case of jealousy, God (race may be his doing too). E.g., in the Ten Commandments, “Remember I am a jealous God”. Something like that…

      I agree that I am jealous over keeping what’s mine and envious over coveting what’s yours, except that people use both words to mean “I want what you have” and therefore so does the ordinary dictionary – that’s its job. The point about jealousy amongst two people or three people may indeed be that you are possessive in your relationship with one friend (or with both) and when they ignore you and prefer the other person, you resent each of them in the appropriate way. For instance if Hugh Grant goes on holiday with Helen Mirren, my jealousy is mainly about my prior feelings for her, but it also produces negative feelings about him. Alas, she does not know that I exist (I think), and now if she finds out that I do, it will be rather alarming for her.

      Like

  2. Please understand a lot of people speak native English this is not the same as American English.

    Like

  3. Matteo Marcantonio // October 10, 2017 at 10:07 pm // Reply

    What about adding also “disease” vs “pathogen” ? see here: http://www.cell.com/trends/parasitology/fulltext/S1471-4922(16)30188-X

    Like

  4. Sluggo Rigor // October 10, 2017 at 10:36 pm // Reply

    This is informative especially to immigrant communities. Can we ask for permission to reprint this?

    Like

    • Frontiers Communications // October 11, 2017 at 10:57 am // Reply

      Thank you for your interest and yes of course you may republish the article. We just ask that you include a link (or the full reference, if it will be printed) to the original research article.

      Like

  5. There are no biological differences in “race” besides pigmentation in the skin. This article confuses the terminology.

    Like

    • Sluggo Rigor // October 11, 2017 at 8:13 pm // Reply

      Please check also on the article’s use of words “affect” and (I believe the more apt in context of the article) “effect.” Thank you. -Sluggo Rigor

      On Wed, Oct 11, 2017 at 1:57 AM, Science & research news | Frontiers | Open-access publisher wrote:

      > Vickie Lynn commented: “There are no biological differences in “race” > besides pigmentation in the skin. This article confuses the terminology.” >

      Like

  6. GrT. Every one must read it several times to
    Use them rightly

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s