Bedtime protein for bigger gains? Here’s the scoop
Downing a casein shake just before sleep increases muscle mass and strength gains from resistance training, without ‘making you fat’ — but is the effect any different to your regular post-workout protein supplement?
— by Matthew Prior, Frontiers science writer
Drinking a casein shake just before overnight sleep increases gains in muscle mass and strength in response to resistance exercise. But to date, no study has directly addressed whether this effect is due to increased total protein intake only, or if a bedtime beverage is better.
According to a review published in Frontiers in Nutrition, existing findings nevertheless suggest that overnight sleep is a unique nutritional window for boosting muscle gains – while late-night protein calories needn’t increase body fat or disrupt sleep.
The Impact of Pre-sleep Protein Ingestion on the Skeletal Muscle Adaptive Response to Exercise in Humans: An Update
► Read original article
► Download original article (pdf)
Casein point: Snijders’ seminal study
“Several one-night studies have shown that pre-sleep protein intake increases muscle protein synthesis during overnight sleep in young adults” says lead author Dr. Tim Snijders, Assistant Professor at Maastricht University. “These have fueled the idea that over a longer period, a pre-sleep protein supplement can maximize the strength and muscle mass gains during regular resistance exercise training.”
Snijders’ 2015 study is the most compelling demonstration to date for this.
His team put 44 healthy young men on a 12-week lifting program. Half were given a nightly pre-sleep protein shake with about 30g of casein and 15 grams of carbs, while the other half got an energy-free drink.
The training was effective – both groups ended with a bigger squat (one rep max) and bigger quads – but the protein-before-bed group gained significantly more muscle strength and size.
Is pre-sleep protein consumption better?
But are muscle gains boosted by pre-sleep protein per se, or just higher total intake of protein and calories?
Just one study has attempted – unsuccessfully – to test this question. It showed that fat-free mass gains over 8 weeks of unaltered training in regular lifters were greater (+1.2 kg vs +0.4 kg) with a nightly casein supplement, compared to the same supplement taken in the morning. The difference was not statistically significant however, perhaps because there were only 26 participants.
“Based on our own studies, we calculated that a huge number of participants would be needed to prove whether a difference might exist in response to pre-sleep protein, versus protein intake at other times of the day,” explains Snijders.
However, there are already numerous indirect indicators that pre-sleep protein specifically is beneficial for healthy young lifters.
Related: Recommended daily protein intake too low for the elderly
Sleep is a unique opportunity for muscle recovery and growth
Fundamentally, pre-sleep protein can be used to improve protein intake distribution over the day, says Snijders.
Muscles can only grow and repair themselves when the right building blocks – amino acids from protein – are available in the blood. But unlike blood glucose, the body does not store and release amino acids to maintain near-constant circulating levels.
“A survey of over 500 athletes found they were typically consuming at total of more than 1.2g protein per kilo of bodyweight across three main meals, but only a paltry 7g of protein as an evening snack. As a result, lower levels of amino acids would be available for muscle growth during overnight sleep.”
But if pre-sleep protein consumption allows muscles to cram in more amino acids at night, will they simply use less during the day? Apparently not, claims Snijders.
“The muscle-building effects of protein supplementation at each meal seem to be additive. In one study we found that the consumption of ample amounts of protein (60g whey) before overnight sleep did not alter the muscle protein synthetic response to a high-protein breakfast the following morning.
“What’s more, others have shown that adding a protein supplement at bedtime does not affect appetite the following morning – so it is unlikely to compromise total protein or calorie intake.”
Bedtime protein won’t ‘make you fat’ or ruin your sleep
While the case for pre-sleep protein remains preliminary, is there any harm in trying it? After all, it does involve consuming calories just before a long period of inactivity.
The evidence is sparse, but encouraging.
“In the 8-week morning vs evening casein study, the additional consumption of protein calories did not result in any increase in fat mass despite the fact that exercise volume did not change,” reports Snijders. “But again, these results should be interpreted with caution due to the low number of volunteers included.
“Supporting this, another group found in 11 young active men that a pre-sleep casein shake actually increased the rate of fat burning the following day. This might be because casein ingestion reduces the insulin response to subsequent meals, which pushes your body to use more fat.”
Based on the results of these studies at least, pre-bed protein consumption, especially casein, doesn’t appear to ‘make you fat.’ Indeed, it appears to actually increase fat metabolism.
Finally, pre-sleep protein may be what keeps Snijders up at night – but it won’t stop you getting your well-earned rest.
“It has been consistently shown that pre-sleep protein ingestion has no effect on sleep onset latency or sleep quality.”
In conclusion: we don’t yet have conclusive evidence for adding pre-sleep protein supplement to your fitness regime: but it’s worth a try – and it’s worth further research.
Original article: The Impact of Pre-sleep Protein Ingestion on the Skeletal Muscle Adaptive Response to Exercise in Humans: An Update
REPUBLISHING GUIDELINES: Open access and sharing research is part of Frontiers’ mission. Unless otherwise noted, you can republish articles posted in the Frontiers news blog — as long as you include a link back to the original research. Selling the articles is not allowed.
It’s a really good call, taking protein shake before sleeping. You can try different timings to consume protein but this may prove to be the best, surely gonna try this.
Perhaps the most relevant element to mention is that a difference–if it does exist and operate in the face of EQUAL calories and protein yet at a different time–may be nominal, at best (thus the apparent need for many more subjects to show a difference).
Perhaps the most important elements to highlight are the parity and disparity between each study when making inter-study comparisons: the “resistance training maturity” of the subjects, and the protein sources. Snijders’ 2015 study used UNtrained subjects undergoing a 12-week resistance training (RT) program and a protein supplement comprised of 50% casein and 50% predigested casein (27.5 g of total casein). This latter casein source elicits a different blood insulin response, and faster digestion and absorption kinetics than “casein”; it is made by a large Dutch company (DSM) that has sponsored several studies performed by Snijders’ Dutch team. In contradistinction, the “8-week morning vs evening casein study” used resistance TRAINED subjects (ranging from > 1 – > 5 years of RT experience) and only intact (non-digested) casein (at an excessive dose of 54 g of casein). This latter study also enrolled men and WOMEN whereas Snijders et al. had only young males.
Apples to apples, trained state to trained state, protein source to protein source, and gender to gender, are essential when assessing a suite of studies that ostensibly appears similar. The work from Luc van Loon’s lab at Maastricht U (where Snijders hails from) is always exceptional. I look forward to a robust, adequately powered study from this preeminent group.
Having a protein shake before bed could helps in weight loss, but total caloric intake should be measured. Recent studies suggest consuming 40 grams of protein before bed is recommended to best stimulate muscle protein growth rates in sleep.
I always suggest trying a lean protein, fresh fruit, vegetable, handful of nuts, or a serving of a whole grain. A protein-rich snack will help your body continue to burn fat. Thanks for sharing this wonderful post with us on bedtime protein.